Scott Standage, MD, is a Stanford-trained specialist in physical medicine and rehabilitation (PM&R) with more than two decades of clinical experience in musculoskeletal and neurological rehabilitation. He’s practiced medicine at leading institutions, including Stanford and Santa Clara Valley Medical Center, and currently sees patients at an outpatient clinic in California. After being misdiagnosed and treated with powerful psychiatric medications for a sleep disorder, he endured years of medical maltreatment that cost him his career, his reputation, and nearly his life. His new book, White Coats and Black Swans: A Doctor’s Descent into Misdiagnosis and Madness (Amplify Publishing, Oct. 13, 2026), advocates for diagnostic reform, mental health accountability, and evidence-based treatment pathways. Learn more at scottstandage.com.

1. You entered medical school at 41. What prompted such a significant career change?
Before medicine, I worked in hospitality and travel, including on cruise ships. Eventually, a passenger complaining about lukewarm coffee just didn’t resonate with me anymore. Someone who couldn’t breathe—that resonated deeply. It helped clarify what I wanted to do with the rest of my life.
I wasn’t desperate for a career. I’d had a well-paying job managing a conference resort. I wanted a path that would make my impact larger.
My father had been a doctor for more than 40 years, so I asked what he thought. He told me, “It’s all wrong if you’re pursuing an occupation. It needs to be a calling for you to be good at it and enjoy it.”
That stayed with me. I moved to Boston, where I didn’t know a soul, and started medical school after 20 years out of school. My degree was in cultural anthropology, so I wasn’t exactly arriving straight from the biochemistry lab.
2. What does the title White Coats and Black Swans mean?
For centuries, Europeans assumed all swans were white. Then they encountered black swans in Australia. So much for that theory.
I had some assumptions of my own. I thought doctors would approach my illness with the curiosity and care our profession was supposed to require. If treatment wasn’t working, they’d investigate. If the evidence didn’t fit their diagnosis, they’d take another look. I was a physician myself, so I thought I knew how this worked, but then I became the patient.
The white coats represent the authority I trusted. The black swans are the things I hadn’t imagined could happen within that system. As I say in the book, they arrived in a flock.
3. Did you set out to tell a personal story, or to expose broader problems in healthcare?
I can’t really separate the two.
I’d gone looking for help because I couldn’t stay awake. An initial diagnosis of obstructive sleep apnea was dismissed, and I was treated for a different sleep disorder. With my apnea inadequately treated and powerful medications affecting my brain, I eventually became manic and psychotic. Then came the psychiatric admissions, and my life fell apart.
That’s my story. But how did so many doctors miss so many chances to figure out what was happening?
A diagnostic error sounds like a technicality until you see what it does to someone’s life. Mine affected my work, relationships, finances, freedom—even my ability to know what was real.
I especially want doctors to read the book. They’ll recognize the hospitals, the terminology, the routines. I want them to see what all that looks like from the bed.
4. What surprised you most about becoming a patient after years of practicing medicine?
At first, I thought I’d be talking to colleagues. Even when I was very ill, I looked forward to explaining things to another physician. Surely we’d sort it out.
That expectation didn’t last long. Now I was the person being watched, assessed, and written about. What I had to say seemed to carry very little weight.
I’m not suggesting they should have believed the Chinese Mafia was after me because I had an MD. (That was one of my delusions at my most paranoid.) I needed help. But I also had a medical history, prescriptions they should have examined, and things to tell them about how I’d been getting worse.
I’d treated people with serious disabilities. I understood that illness could cost you your independence. I hadn’t understood how it felt to keep talking and realize that hardly anything you said seemed to count.
5. Why do you think your diagnosis was not reconsidered as your condition worsened?
Once the diagnosis was in place, almost everything I did seemed to confirm it. My behavior was interpreted through that diagnosis, and treatment kept going along the same track.
What nobody seemed particularly interested in was how I’d gotten there. I had a documented sleep disorder. I was taking medications that deserved a hard look. This hadn’t come out of nowhere.
Differential diagnosis sounds complicated, but the basic question is simple: what else could explain this? Then you investigate the possibilities. As a physician, you have to be willing to say you haven’t figured it out yet.
There was no question that I was psychotic. I certainly was. The question was why.
Once the doctors thought they knew why, the focus seemed to shift to managing me. Their explanation wasn’t getting anything like the scrutiny I was.
6. You describe genuine delusions as well as genuine failures in your care. How should readers understand that distinction?
I thought the Chinese Mafia was pursuing me. I tore apart parts of my house looking for surveillance equipment. I’m not asking anyone to regard those as sensible activities.
But I also had obstructive sleep apnea. I was taking prescribed medications. I’d been telling my doctors I was getting worse. Those things didn’t become imaginary just because I was imagining other things.
You can be wrong about one thing and right about another. Doctors still have to check.
With hindsight, I can now describe both how completely I believed those delusions and how absurd they were. At the time, though, the danger felt real. I needed someone to look beyond what I was saying and investigate what had happened to my brain.
7. What did your experience teach you about autonomy in psychiatric care?
At Washington Hospital, I was facing transfer to another psychiatric facility and the possibility of being confined for a long time. Meanwhile, I thought I was getting clearer.
Other people were deciding where I’d live and what treatment I’d receive. I had very little say in decisions that could change the rest of my life.
Of course there are times when someone is too ill to make safe decisions. I’d been severely impaired myself. But you have to keep checking. People’s conditions change. If you’re going to keep someone locked up, you’d better be looking very carefully at whether the reasons still hold.
When you’re the patient, you become painfully aware that a few sentences in your chart can determine whether you get to leave. And the person writing them may have spent only a few minutes with you.
8. What difference did having someone outside the hospital advocate for you make?
Sharon, my former fiancée, visited often and could see that my thinking was gradually clearing. She knew who I was outside the hospital. She had more to go on than a brief interview on the ward.
When she learned about the proposed transfer, she started looking into alternatives. She offered to provide food, clothing, shelter, and help getting outpatient care. It was her intervention that helped get me discharged.
That’s a lot more than showing up at visiting time and telling someone to hang in there. She did the research, made the arrangements, and took on a substantial responsibility.
I’m enormously grateful. But I keep coming back to this: what happens to the person who doesn’t have a Sharon? Getting a fair assessment shouldn’t depend on whether someone outside the hospital has the time, resources, and determination to fight for you.
9. What was the hardest consequence, and what did beginning again actually look like?
It’s hard to pick the worst loss. My career, finances, independence, reputation—they were all in ruins. Relationships had been badly damaged. As my thinking cleared, I started to understand just how much damage there was. That was an ordeal in itself.
Leaving the hospital gave me a chance to start dealing with it. Sharon gave me somewhere safe to go, but I didn’t walk out of the hospital and back into my old life. That life was gone. There was more suffering ahead.
People want to know when things turned around. I understand that, but there isn’t a neat answer. Being able to think clearly again didn’t give me back everything I’d lost. It didn’t erase what had happened.
What I finally had was a chance to make some decisions for myself again. That mattered, even with all the wreckage still around me.
10. What changes would you most like your book to encourage?
I’d like medical professionals to pay much closer attention to any evidence that challenges their conclusions, especially when a patient isn’t improving.
Look at what was happening before the psychiatric admission. Find out why the person is taking those medications. Talk to people who know them. And if different people on the ward are reporting different things, look into it. In my records, there were descriptions of improvement alongside assessments being used to justify keeping me confined. That should have prompted some questions.
Doctors also need to be able to say, “I may have gotten this wrong”—preferably while there’s still time to do something about it.
Above all, remember there’s a person there. I was frightened, impaired, and sometimes very difficult to understand. I still needed someone to figure out what was happening to me. That was the job.

Scott Standage, MD, is a Stanford-trained specialist in physical medicine and rehabilitation (PM&R) with more than two decades of clinical experience in musculoskeletal and neurological rehabilitation. He’s practiced medicine at leading institutions, including Stanford and Santa Clara Valley Medical Center, and currently sees patients at an outpatient clinic in California. After being misdiagnosed and treated with powerful psychiatric medications for a sleep disorder, he endured years of medical maltreatment that cost him his career, his reputation, and nearly his life. His new book, White Coats and Black Swans: A Doctor’s Descent into Misdiagnosis and Madness (Amplify Publishing, Oct. 13, 2026), advocates for diagnostic reform, mental health accountability, and evidence-based treatment pathways. Learn more at scottstandage.com.
We believe in sharing knowledge with everyone and making a positive change in society through our work and contributions. If you are interested in joining us, please check our ‘About’ page for more information
